Facebook social media iconTwitter social media iconYouTube social media iconSubmit to Reddit

Should sound be described in hertz and decibels, or boom, snap, scoop and smack?

The new Stagescape M20D live sound mixer from Line 6 allows novice users to shape sound in subjective terms rather than scientific measurements. Is this a good idea, or does it merely ring-fence ignorance?

Come on the FREE COURSE TOUR

Line 6's Stagescape M20D is a novel product in that it displays an image of the performers and instruments. Touch an instrument, and you can adjust its various parameters. As a live mixing console without faders, this is truly a ground breaking idea. Whether it is a good idea or not will only be discovered through real-life experience, but it will be interesting to see how well it catches on.

One of the features of this mixer is that it is intended to be easy for novices to use. One way this happens is in the Quick Tweak mode. The operator is presented with a rectangular X-Y display with a 'virtual joystick' that can be positioned anywhere within the rectangle.

For example, when quick tweaking a bass guitar, the display sets the corners of the rectangle to 'boom', 'snap', 'scoop' and 'smack'. The joystick can be positioned to optimize the sound of the bass guitar in these terms.

Clearly, the question arises of what these terms actually mean. I would guess that boom is low bass, snap is high frequency, scoop is a midrange cut and smack possibly high midrange. I'm just guessing, as any operator would have to. (Yes there's a manual. But how often does a live sound operator get to see that?)

These terms, by the way, change according to the instrument being quick tweaked.

I can't see the advantage of these subjective parameters over good old-fashioned hertz and decibels. When you understand, and get a feeling for hertz and decibels, they apply to all audio. All instruments, all ensembles, vocals, choirs, speech and sound effects. Everything. There are maybe thirty or so different musical instruments in common use. How does it make things easier if they each have their own subjective terms?

And if you want to see a more complete list of instruments (and be amazed), then check this page at Wikipedia. It's worth a look.

I'm going to have to nail my colors to the mast and say that I'm a hertz and decibels kind of guy. Line 6's Stagescape M20D fortunately does provide proper terms in their 'Deep Tweak' mode. But I fear that newcomers to live sound will remain in a permanent state of bafflement.

Want more confusion?

Line 6's subjective terms for bass guitar, as stated earlier, are these...

  • Boom
  • Snap
  • Scoop
  • Smack

On the same day that I first heard about this piece of equipment, I also received a 'helpful' chart of instruments and their frequency ranges. It includes subjective terms for a range of instruments, including those it suggests for bass guitar (the same instrument!)...

  • Rumble
  • Bottom
  • Pluck
  • Pop

For me, hertz and decibels it always will be!

By David Mellor Sunday November 11, 2012
Come on the FREE COURSE TOUR
 
 
 

Free Ebook - Equipping Your Home Recording Studio

Set up your home recording studio in the very best way possible. Learn how to select equipment and solftware all the way through from microphones to monitors. Learn more...

How to Avoid These 4 Huge Mistakes In Audio

Are you making these 4 simple mistakes again and again in your home recording studio? They are easy to identify and avoid, so you don't have to. Learn more...