Hands On - The Minimoog (part 2)
The key to synthesis, where a very wide range of sounds is possible, rather than the strictly limited range offered by electronic organs of the Minimoogs period, is in voltage control. This means that every parameter, or at least most parameters, can be controlled from two sources, the knob on the front panel, and a voltage input. For instance, the Voltage Controlled Oscillator, or VCO, can be tuned from the front panel knob, but this can only produce unmusical swoops. But get a keyboard to produce the voltage and the oscillator can produce a series of musical notes. Taking this a stage further and adding a low frequency oscillator, or LFO, can provide a modulating voltage which will create a vibrato effect - mild, rich or extreme in intensity.
Moving along the typical signal path of an analogue synthesiser we find a Voltage Controlled Filter, or VCF, which works in a very similar way: it can be set to whatever cut off frequency you wish on the front panel, and additionally it can take a control voltage input from the keyboard, so the cut off frequency can always stay in the same proportion to the frequency of the note being played. The third source of voltage control for either the VCO or VCF is the Envelope Generator which produces a voltage signal which ramps up and down to create the Attack-Decay-Sustain-Release envelope with which we are familiar from modern digital synthesisers although modern synths have more complex envelopes which may improve the overall sound but do little for controllability. The Envelope Generator may control the pitch of the note being played, the cut off frequency of the filter, or alternatively the Voltage Controlled Amplifier so that the note played has a defined attack, decay etc.
So know you know all about analogue synthesis. Theres not a lot to it in essence because, like all the best ideas, it was brilliantly simple and elegant to start with. I would like to put an analogue synthesiser in front of some of the designers of modern digital synths for a few hours. I am sure that once they had discovered just how controllable they can be that they would be looking at ways they could provide such power of control on their digital monsters which, lets face it, have grown up to be the latter day equivalent of the home organ with presets - and built in drum box if youre lucky.
Thoroughly Modern Mini
When it first occurred to me that the Hands On series could do with looking back at a few past masters of music production, I started doing the rounds of local hire companies who might have had a Minimoog to lend me. But early on, someone mentioned the Midi Moog, as I think it was once known, but is now called the Midi Mini. From what I knew already, this rack mounting MIDI controllable version of the Minimoog was just too tempting to miss, so instead of doing a Hands On review of the original Minimoog, I have opted for the up to date version, a sample of which was kindly lent to me by The Synthesiser Company.
Now some people are going to say that its a sin comparable to putting glasses on the Mona Lisa, but what I have to tell you about the Midi Mini is this: it is the electronics of a real Minimoog, removed from the original wood case and overhauled, and mounted in a 19 box with a new front panel and extra knobs and circuitry to provide all the new functions. Yes. I agree that its a sin and a shame to rip apart these wonderful old musical instruments. I mean, would you consider taking apart an antique Stradivarius violin and modernising it, just because the original didnt match currant tastes? Actually - interesting bit of the history of music technology coming up - this is exactly what happened to almost every example of the work of the old masters of violin making. Their instruments were too soft in tone for the requirements of the up and coming composers of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries so that one by one they were taken apart and internally and externally modified so that they would perform better. This exactly parallels what is happening now. They didnt build new violins to replace the old because they had lost the secret of how to do it. No one, to my knowledge, is currently building an instrument with the sound and controllability of the Minimoog because production techniques have moved on to digital integrated circuits and the old ways of manufacture would be uneconomic. So now we are faced with the fact that to make a Minimoog usable for modern music, it must have a MIDI interface, and this inevitably means altering the original. And once you have made the decision to modify a Moog, why not go the whole way and bring it totally up to date as a rack mounting unit? If you object to this, you had better start up a synthesiser manufacturing business and develop an alternative product because thats the only way this is going to stop.